A Performance Case Study
February 9, 2011
I’m a sucker for a good performance case study. So, when I came across a general request for performance improvement suggestions at Inspiredology, I couldn’t help but experiment a bit.
The site runs on WordPress and is heavy on the graphics as it’s a site geared towards web designers. I inquired to the site administrators about grabbing a static copy of their home page and using it for a case study on our blog. My tools of choice for optimization were webpagetest.org and YSlow.
Here are the results of a 4-step optimization in visual form:
|Inspiredology’s complete homepage.|
The graph on the left shows the page load time in seconds for a first time view. Throughout optimization, page load time goes from 13.412 seconds to 9.212 seconds. Each step had a measurable impact. The graph on the right shows the page load time in seconds for a repeated view, and this goes from 7.329 seconds to 2.563 seconds throughout optimization. The first optimization step (CSS spriting and file combination) yielded a large performance improvement. I’m not sure why there’s a slight performance decrease between step 3 and step 4.
And here’s a summary of the changes involved in each step:
- Addition of CSS Sprites: I wrote about CSS Sprites a while back and A List Apart has an older but still relevant article on CSS Sprites here. Repeating elements like navigation components, icons, and buttons are suitable for CSS sprites. Article or page-specific images are not typically suitable for CSS sprites. For Inspiredology’s site, I created two sprited images—one with a large amount of navigation components, and one with some of their large background images. You can find a great tool for building CSS rules from a sprited image here.
- Image compression with jpegtran, pngcrush, convert. I use pngcrush often. I read about jpegtran in Yahoo’s Best Practices for Speeding Up Your Web Site. I wrote a bit about image compression a while ago and briefly experimented with image compression using imagemagick on Inspiredology’s images.
- Serving gzipped content with mod_deflate: Also a fairly standard optimization suggestion. Although, I should note I had some issues gzipping a couple of the files and since the site was in a temporary location, I didn’t spend much time troubleshooting.
A side-by-side comparison of webpagetest.org’s original versus step 4 results highlights the reduction of requests in the waterfall and the large reduction in requests on the repeat view:
At this point, webpagetest.org suggests the following changes:
- Gzipping the remaining components has a potential of reducing total bytes of the first request by ~10%.
- Additional image compression has the potential of reducing total bytes of the first request by about ~6%. This metric is based on their image compression check: “JPEG—Within 10% of a photoshop quality 50 will pass, up to 50% larger will warn and anything larger than that will fail.” Quite a few of Inspiredology’s jpgs did not pass this test and could be optimized further.
- Use a CDN. This is a common optimization suggestion, but the cost of a CDN isn’t always justified for smaller sites.
I would suggest:
- Revisiting CSS spriting to further optimize. I only spent a short time spriting and didn’t work out all the kinks. There were a few requests that I didn’t sprite because they were repeating elements, but repeating elements can be sprited together. Another 5 requests might be eliminated with additional CSS spriting.
- Database optimization: Again, there’s no database in play in this static page experiment. But there’s always room for improvement on database optimization. Josh Tolley recently made performance improvements for one of our clients running on Rails with postgreSQL using pgsi, our open source postgreSQL performance reporting tool, and had outrageously impressive benchmarked improvements.
- I just read an article about CSS selectors. The combined.css file I created for this case study has 2000 lines. Although there might be only a small win with optimization here, surely optimization and cleanup of that file can be beneficial.
- I recently wrote about several jQuery tips, including performance optimization techniques. This isn’t going to improve the serving of static assets, but it would be another customer-facing enhancement that can improve the usability of the site.
I highly recommend reading Yahoo’s Best Practices on Speeding Up Your Web Site. They have a great summary of performance recommendations, covering the topics described in this article and lots more.